Hamburger or Steak?

It was 60s Idol last night. I just gotta say WOW about the set this year. It's over the top. Looks really good though. Also during one of the breaks I saw a commercial for Finding Neverland coming to DVD on March 22 so yay! Ok so quite a few Idols did songs that ppl have covered in past seasons, both successfully, and then not so. I was really pissed about most, but happy about some.

Jessica Sierra - Boring but ok singing

Anwar -Nice hair. Don't sing House is not a Home! What is wrong with you! There is nothing you can bring to that song, Tamayra blew it up and Ruben did good enough after that, THERE IS NO MORE ROOM FOR THIS SONG. BOO!

Mikalah - When I first saw the outfit and the "makeover" I was like, wow you look beau-- is that really your stupid pink bra? Grrr and the singing was bad. Someone already sang this better than you in season 2.

Constantine - YAY I'M FINALLY HAPPY! THAT'S MY BOY! BLUE SHIRT! YAY!

Lindsey - I smell Kim Caldwell. Kim C and Fantasia both did this song already, what' wrong with you?

Anthony - Ruben did this and failed, I think Justin Guarini did it and failed, someone in season 3 may have done it and failed. Congrats for doing an excellent job with a cursed song! I had always said the next time I heard that needed to be a girl cuz Anne Murray did it best. Good job though :)

Nadia - Girl you look beautiful! You sang perfect! Maybe it got a little morbid at the end but you did a damn good job overall!
Simon's comment: In a competition full of hamburgers, you are a steak.
I will never watch AI in the same way again...I keep picturing McDonalds cheeseburgers dancing and singing now :)

Bo - You rock dude, literally :) I don't really like that song but you made it good for me.
Is Bo married? I saw the ring on his finger but I'm not sure who's taken this season. I know Scott has a son, but nothing has been mentioned.

Vonzell - She looked beautiful! Sounded like the origional! Yay.

Scott - You can't come close to competing with George on that song, let alone that Ruben did it as well. Nice job creating your own ending though.

Carrie - At first the way you sang the pickup notes was annoying, but you got more into it halfway through the song. Not bad, wasn't liking the clothes though.

Nikko - Welcome back! Good song, looked nice.

WHO SHOULD GO HOME? Anyone who sang something that had previously been done.