Idol 4 Semi finals Week 2 guys

Whew what a title! Ok so I rushed home to see Idol last night but missed Mario. I don't care, we already had Justin Guarini and I refuse to vote for him no matter how good or bad or well dressed or whatever he does. Last week I hated Anwar Robinson's performance but this week loved it. He can stay another week or so.
A lot of people want Joseph Murena to go home. I want him to stay. His voice is very unique to the now 4 seasons of Idol that have been brought to us. He sounds like BJ Thomas. I would love to hear him sing "This time the giirrrlll is gonna staaaaay for more than just a daaaay." :) David Brown can just go. I didn't care for him either week. Boring. Poor Constantine Maroulis. I loved him so much in the beginning, then he did Kiss from a Rose and I was disappointed. Now I just want him to die from screaming like that. Didn't even really care for the song. Scott Savol is really kewl. He's like the white Ruben. I think his voice is a bit smoother actually, but his gaining weight and doing that cover the fat face with a strange beard thing that Ruben had in the beginning. Now to Ruben's defence I hear he looks like he lost 100 lbs. I would like proof, I don't really care for the dude, GO CLAY AIKEN!!! GO CLAY GO CLAY!
Travis Tucker is absolutely gorgeous! He will never have my vote though cuz he doesn't sing well and I'm not just gonna vote for a pretty face, though I drool when I see him. Don't show your body off so much, I don't care if you can dance, this isn't Fame. They didn't bother renewing that show for a reason. Anybody remember who won? Didn't think so. ANYWAY Nikko Smith did a much better job this week. He did great with Part Time Lover last week showcasing his upper range, now we see he can control the lower as well. He can growl and not sound horse either. Very nice, interesting song choice, didn't know they would allow that.
I just talked about Clay Aiken, now it's Anthony Federov. I still prefer my Claybaby, but Anthony can really sing. He worried me in the beginning cuz he sounded weak, but he was just building us up :) He dresses well and looks good, I don't think he needs a makeover, but I can't tell. I always want to hold my throat when I see where they did his surgery. I hope Anthony stays. Bo didn't get my praise this week. Sorry, didn't like the song, didn't understand it, I'm not a rock person. I sound like Simon yikes!
I want David and Travis to go home. Also I don't like how this is shaping up for the boys. They seem to do a lot of R&B stuff, then rockers do their thing. It's not workin for me, but I love R&B so grrrr. Can't wait to hear the girls tonight.
Melissa